Brace Yourself,
BTAC is coming! September 19th marked the release of the 2017 Buffalo Trace
Antique Collection. Similar to previous years, this years collection includes
the five sought after whiskys we know and love. Every year I hope for a change
or addition to the collection (Elmer T. Lee) but it's hard to complain when you
see your favorites are all back. Below are tasting notes for each of the 2017
Buffalo Trace Antique Collection whiskeys as well as a ranking.
2017 Sazerac Rye
90 proof
18 years
25 barrels (2,637 bottles)
Nose: Fluffy vanilla cream balanced by green apples, pines, and mint leaves. Scents
of cinnamon and a heavy dose of toasted oak add depth and balance.
Taste: Cinnamon toast crunch
in a glass. This is fantastic! Vanilla icing fights against 18 years’ worth of
wood. It’s chewy and bold, yet delicate.
Finish: Long with a mixture of
baking spices and oak.
Rating: A (Great)
2017 Thomas H. Handy Rye
127.2 proof
6 years and 5 months
72 barrels selected (14,021 bottles)
Nose: Vibrant
with a bouquet of Fruits- berries, citrus, apples. It’s sweet with a touch of
caramel. There is an element of spice presenting as an upbeat, black pepper
pop.
Taste: Initial waves of
rye bread, fig, and pepper spice. The fruit notes found on the nose are subtle
and less expressive on the palate.
Finish: Dry with a lingering, allspice finish.
Rating: B+ (Very Good)
2017 George T. Stagg Bourbon
129.2 proof
15 years and 3 month
309 barrels (37,998 bottles)
Nose: An extremely deep sweetness
suppressed by tobacco and coffee beans. Fudge and sugar cane break through
after a few minutes of air. Toasted oak lingers at the lip of the glass.
Taste: Sweet sugars saturate my tongue. Decadent fudge
mixes with flavors of tobacco and espresso.
Finish: Long with spent tobacco and a fading
sweetness.
Rating: A (Great)
2017 Eagle Rare Bourbon
90 proof
17 year 3 months
36 barrels selected (1,461 bottles)
Nose: Gentle herbal spices sprinkled on piles of
toasted wood. The sweetness is vibrant- an aroma reminiscent of a moon-pie
pastry.
Taste: Spice kicks into high gear and presents as a
pepper pop on the palate. It’s savory with tobacco and wood notes. Sweet sugar
fades before you notice it was ever there.
Finish: Long with oak tannin that leaves the mouth watering.
Rating: B+ (Very Good)
2017 William Larue Weller Bourbon
128.2 proof
12 years and 6 months
165 barrels (5,619 bottles)
Nose: Sweetness wrapped in baking
spices. red hot candies, dipped in vanilla cream. leather adds a balance
which brings us down to earth.
Taste: Bold
flavors on the nose spring to life. Cinnamon and nutmeg poke at the tastebuds. Marshmallows
and toffee play perfectly with against a strong toasted oak.
Finish: Long with a sweet spice. A touch
of oak keeps my mouth watering.
Rating: A+ (Great)
If I could only purchase one bottle, I would prioritize them as such:
1st: William Larue Weller
2nd: Sazerac Rye
3rd: Geoge T. Stagg
4th: Eagle Rare 17
5th: Thomas H. Handy
None of these whiskeys disappointed! The William Larue Weller and Sazerac Rye seem to be noticeably better than last year. It's worth noting that the suggested retail price per bottle is $90. Good luck and happy hunting!